{
  "runDate": "2026-10-06",
  "runAt": "2026-10-06T03:54:03.714Z",
  "aspectRequested": "16:9 (reference chain: 3:2)",
  "seedPrompt": "A photorealistic architectural photograph of a large contemporary villa in Bali, Indonesia — a modern architect's reinterpretation of the Javanese joglo, not a traditional house. The joglo is present only as structure and silhouette: a steep two-tiered pyramidal roof in alang-alang thatch with deep clean overhanging eaves, carried on four heavy dark-stained ironwood soko guru posts and plain squared beams. Every surface is flat, planed and unornamented — no carving, no traditional motifs, no decorative fretwork anywhere.\n\nA substantial two-storey private house about twenty-five metres wide, not a garden pavilion. Under the joglo roof at the centre is a deep open-sided living veranda on a honed dark volcanic stone plinth, with three wide stone steps down to the garden. Two long lower wings extend left and right under simple pitched thatch roofs: enclosed rooms clad in flush vertical dark-stained timber boards, with tall frameless floor-to-ceiling glazing and slim dark metal frames. Upstairs bedrooms open onto a continuous first-floor balcony with a plain horizontal timber slat railing running the width of the facade.\n\nA rectangular swimming pool in the foreground, parallel to the facade, edged in dark volcanic stone. Mown lawn between the pool and the steps. A frangipani tree at the left of the pool. A coconut palm grove behind the villa on the right, jungle ridge on the horizon.\n\nSoft flat overcast midday daylight, no direct sun, no strong shadows, neutral white balance. A wide shot photographed at eye level in three-quarter view from the garden side. The entire villa is inside the frame with clearmargin on both sides: the far end of the left wing and the far end of the right wing are both fully visible, and nothing is cut off by the edges of the picture. The whole length of the pool is visible too. No people, no text.",
  "keepClause": "Keep everything else in the image identical — the same building, the same materials, the same objects in the same places.\n\nDo not change the camera in any way: no zooming in or out, no cropping or re-framing, no change of focal length, viewpoint, height or angle, no shifting or rescaling of the scene. The horizon line, the edges of the frame and the position and size of every existing element within the frame must stay exactly where they are. If something new is added, fit it into the existing view rather than pulling the camera back to make room.\n\nKeep exactly the same soft flat overcast midday daylight: do not change the time of day, the weather, the sky, the direction of the light, the shadows or the colour temperature.",
  "lightingPolicy": "constant — flat overcast midday daylight, locked in the seed and re-stated in every edit; no edit touches light, sky, weather or time of day",
  "framingPolicy": "constant — every edit forbids zoom, crop, re-framing, focal length and viewpoint change; additions must fit the existing view rather than pull the camera back",
  "controlRegions": [
    "the sky",
    "the coconut palm grove behind the villa on the right",
    "the jungle ridge on the horizon",
    "the overcast daylight itself"
  ],
  "harness": "scripts/bench10-edit-chain.mjs",
  "seedHarness": "scripts/bench10-seeds.mjs",
  "metricsScript": "scripts/bench10-edit-chains-metrics.py",
  "commonLongEdgePx": 768,
  "webFrameWidthPx": 720,
  "seedSharpnessReference": 1.0,
  "edits": [
    {
      "step": 1,
      "slug": "pool",
      "kind": "form",
      "zone": "foreground",
      "instruct": "Replace the rectangular swimming pool with an L-shaped pool that wraps around the near corner of the pavilion."
    },
    {
      "step": 2,
      "slug": "tiles",
      "kind": "material",
      "zone": "roof, large",
      "instruct": "Replace the alang-alang thatch on the roof with dark grey clay roof tiles, keeping the same roof shape and pitch."
    },
    {
      "step": 3,
      "slug": "teak",
      "kind": "material",
      "zone": "structure",
      "instruct": "Change the four heavy ironwood posts and the beams above them from dark stained timber to pale natural honey-coloured teak."
    },
    {
      "step": 4,
      "slug": "bale",
      "kind": "add",
      "zone": "mid-ground",
      "instruct": "Add a small square open bale bengong pavilion with its own thatched roof at the far end of the pool."
    },
    {
      "step": 5,
      "slug": "no-frangi",
      "kind": "remove",
      "zone": "left edge",
      "instruct": "Remove the frangipani tree at the left of the pool, leaving open lawn in its place."
    },
    {
      "step": 6,
      "slug": "pebbles",
      "kind": "texture",
      "zone": "foreground, whole",
      "instruct": "Replace the mown lawn between the pool and the steps with white pebble ground and large flat stepping stones."
    },
    {
      "step": 7,
      "slug": "glass",
      "kind": "form",
      "zone": "centre of facade",
      "instruct": "Enclose the open-sided central living veranda with full-height sliding glass panels set between the timber posts."
    },
    {
      "step": 8,
      "slug": "second",
      "kind": "add",
      "zone": "composition",
      "instruct": "Add a separate single-storey guest building to the right of the villa, in the same timber and thatch, linked to the main house by a low covered walkway."
    },
    {
      "step": 9,
      "slug": "mahkota",
      "kind": "detail",
      "zone": "revisits step 2",
      "instruct": "Add a continuous narrow glazed rooflight strip running along the ridge of the main joglo roof."
    },
    {
      "step": 10,
      "slug": "channel",
      "kind": "fine geom",
      "zone": "revisits step 1",
      "instruct": "Add a narrow shallow stone water channel running from the edge of the pool to a carved stone spout in the garden wall."
    }
  ],
  "models": [
    {
      "key": "gpt25flare",
      "label": "GPT Image 2.5 Flare (medium)",
      "id": "openai/gpt-image-2.5-flare",
      "vendor": "OpenAI",
      "request": {
        "quality": "medium",
        "aspect_ratio": "16:9"
      },
      "stepsCompleted": 10,
      "seedSize": [
        1536,
        864
      ],
      "deliveredSizes": [
        [
          1536,
          864
        ]
      ],
      "analysisGrid": [
        768,
        432
      ],
      "seedCostUsd": 0.01038,
      "seedLatencyMs": 14400,
      "costPerEditUsd": 0.01974,
      "totalEditCostUsd": 0.19745,
      "latencyMedianMs": 46957,
      "latencyTotalMs": 416707,
      "latencyFromFileTimestampsSteps": [],
      "costFlatCatalogSteps": [],
      "finalSharpness": 1.4599,
      "finalStructureIoU": 0.1041,
      "finalDriftFromSeed": 35.49,
      "medianStepDelta": 7.58,
      "minSharpness": 0.9226,
      "maxSharpness": 1.5093,
      "atmosphereShiftFinal": [
        10.99,
        4.14,
        -3.0
      ],
      "atmosphereShiftMagnitude": 12.12,
      "skyShiftFinal": [
        -12.03,
        -12.82,
        -12.17
      ],
      "skyShiftMagnitude": 21.38,
      "steps": [
        {
          "step": 0,
          "slug": "seed",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-00",
          "latencyMs": 14400,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.01038,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 0.0,
          "driftFromSeed": 0.0,
          "sharpness": 1.0,
          "structureIoU": 1.0,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            141.59,
            151.14,
            136.12
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 1,
          "slug": "pool",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-01",
          "latencyMs": 49525,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019728,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 11.14,
          "driftFromSeed": 11.14,
          "sharpness": 0.9226,
          "structureIoU": 0.5314,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            145.94,
            154.1,
            133.68
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            4.35,
            2.96,
            -2.44
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -0.81,
            -1.0,
            -0.85
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 2,
          "slug": "tiles",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-02",
          "latencyMs": 17070,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019753,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 8.53,
          "driftFromSeed": 16.97,
          "sharpness": 1.1829,
          "structureIoU": 0.2631,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            144.55,
            152.29,
            132.19
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            2.96,
            1.15,
            -3.93
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -2.55,
            -2.94,
            -2.66
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 3,
          "slug": "teak",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-03",
          "latencyMs": 46298,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019748,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 7.72,
          "driftFromSeed": 20.8,
          "sharpness": 1.2658,
          "structureIoU": 0.2096,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            145.1,
            152.0,
            132.13
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            3.51,
            0.86,
            -3.99
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -4.08,
            -4.29,
            -3.9
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 4,
          "slug": "bale",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-04",
          "latencyMs": 47392,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019743,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 7.55,
          "driftFromSeed": 23.41,
          "sharpness": 1.2185,
          "structureIoU": 0.1682,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            149.73,
            156.07,
            136.12
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            8.14,
            4.93,
            0.0
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -4.22,
            -3.96,
            -3.8
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 5,
          "slug": "no-frangi",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-05",
          "latencyMs": 46523,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019733,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 7.32,
          "driftFromSeed": 25.85,
          "sharpness": 1.1993,
          "structureIoU": 0.1414,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            149.18,
            155.09,
            135.21
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            7.59,
            3.95,
            -0.91
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -5.74,
            -5.57,
            -5.84
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 6,
          "slug": "pebbles",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-06",
          "latencyMs": 47617,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019738,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 7.18,
          "driftFromSeed": 27.95,
          "sharpness": 1.372,
          "structureIoU": 0.123,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            149.39,
            155.43,
            134.35
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            7.8,
            4.29,
            -1.77
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -5.59,
            -5.54,
            -5.63
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 7,
          "slug": "glass",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-07",
          "latencyMs": 17013,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019728,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 7.61,
          "driftFromSeed": 30.4,
          "sharpness": 1.477,
          "structureIoU": 0.119,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            150.4,
            155.63,
            134.5
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            8.81,
            4.49,
            -1.62
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -6.59,
            -6.91,
            -6.76
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 8,
          "slug": "second",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-08",
          "latencyMs": 45765,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019798,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 8.57,
          "driftFromSeed": 32.32,
          "sharpness": 1.5093,
          "structureIoU": 0.1119,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            150.98,
            155.87,
            134.39
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            9.39,
            4.73,
            -1.73
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -8.0,
            -8.35,
            -7.92
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 9,
          "slug": "mahkota",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-09",
          "latencyMs": 48082,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019723,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 6.95,
          "driftFromSeed": 33.82,
          "sharpness": 1.4502,
          "structureIoU": 0.1086,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            151.29,
            155.13,
            133.81
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            9.7,
            3.99,
            -2.31
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -9.81,
            -10.49,
            -9.95
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 10,
          "slug": "channel",
          "frame": "gpt25flare-10",
          "latencyMs": 51422,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.019753,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1536,
          "height": 864,
          "stepDelta": 7.12,
          "driftFromSeed": 35.49,
          "sharpness": 1.4599,
          "structureIoU": 0.1041,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            152.58,
            155.28,
            133.12
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            10.99,
            4.14,
            -3.0
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -12.03,
            -12.82,
            -12.17
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "key": "flux3",
      "label": "FLUX.3 Image (1K)",
      "id": "black-forest-labs/flux-3-image",
      "vendor": "Black Forest Labs",
      "request": {
        "resolution": "1K",
        "aspect_ratio": "16:9"
      },
      "stepsCompleted": 10,
      "seedSize": [
        1360,
        768
      ],
      "deliveredSizes": [
        [
          1360,
          768
        ]
      ],
      "analysisGrid": [
        768,
        434
      ],
      "seedCostUsd": 0.024,
      "seedLatencyMs": 26800,
      "costPerEditUsd": 0.024,
      "totalEditCostUsd": 0.24,
      "latencyMedianMs": 69731,
      "latencyTotalMs": 662538,
      "latencyFromFileTimestampsSteps": [
        1,
        2,
        3,
        4,
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8
      ],
      "costFlatCatalogSteps": [
        1,
        2,
        3,
        4,
        5,
        6,
        7,
        8
      ],
      "finalSharpness": 1.1771,
      "finalStructureIoU": 0.2425,
      "finalDriftFromSeed": 27.28,
      "medianStepDelta": 3.29,
      "minSharpness": 1.0296,
      "maxSharpness": 1.3666,
      "atmosphereShiftFinal": [
        10.88,
        9.01,
        6.25
      ],
      "atmosphereShiftMagnitude": 15.45,
      "skyShiftFinal": [
        1.74,
        1.99,
        3.45
      ],
      "skyShiftMagnitude": 4.35,
      "steps": [
        {
          "step": 0,
          "slug": "seed",
          "frame": "flux3-00",
          "latencyMs": 26800,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 0.0,
          "driftFromSeed": 0.0,
          "sharpness": 1.0,
          "structureIoU": 1.0,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            139.85,
            141.31,
            129.88
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 1,
          "slug": "pool",
          "frame": "flux3-01",
          "latencyMs": 107925,
          "latencySource": "file-mtime (run interrupted before raw.json was written)",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "flat catalog price, equal to every recorded FLUX.3 call",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 6.47,
          "driftFromSeed": 6.47,
          "sharpness": 1.0296,
          "structureIoU": 0.804,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            146.16,
            145.42,
            129.32
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            6.31,
            4.11,
            -0.56
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 2,
          "slug": "tiles",
          "frame": "flux3-02",
          "latencyMs": 63573,
          "latencySource": "file-mtime (run interrupted before raw.json was written)",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "flat catalog price, equal to every recorded FLUX.3 call",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 4.11,
          "driftFromSeed": 10.58,
          "sharpness": 1.3025,
          "structureIoU": 0.5243,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            144.84,
            144.35,
            128.4
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            4.99,
            3.04,
            -1.48
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -1.32,
            -1.08,
            -0.94
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 3,
          "slug": "teak",
          "frame": "flux3-03",
          "latencyMs": 80638,
          "latencySource": "file-mtime (run interrupted before raw.json was written)",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "flat catalog price, equal to every recorded FLUX.3 call",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 3.6,
          "driftFromSeed": 13.86,
          "sharpness": 1.3666,
          "structureIoU": 0.4957,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            144.84,
            144.35,
            128.4
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            4.99,
            3.04,
            -1.48
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -1.32,
            -1.08,
            -0.94
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 4,
          "slug": "bale",
          "frame": "flux3-04",
          "latencyMs": 45041,
          "latencySource": "file-mtime (run interrupted before raw.json was written)",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "flat catalog price, equal to every recorded FLUX.3 call",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 3.48,
          "driftFromSeed": 16.61,
          "sharpness": 1.3406,
          "structureIoU": 0.4674,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            145.03,
            144.18,
            128.95
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            5.18,
            2.87,
            -0.93
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -1.32,
            -1.08,
            -0.94
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 5,
          "slug": "no-frangi",
          "frame": "flux3-05",
          "latencyMs": 69106,
          "latencySource": "file-mtime (run interrupted before raw.json was written)",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "flat catalog price, equal to every recorded FLUX.3 call",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 8.62,
          "driftFromSeed": 24.61,
          "sharpness": 1.0364,
          "structureIoU": 0.2777,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            150.49,
            150.12,
            135.98
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            10.64,
            8.81,
            6.1
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            1.74,
            1.99,
            3.45
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 6,
          "slug": "pebbles",
          "frame": "flux3-06",
          "latencyMs": 83552,
          "latencySource": "file-mtime (run interrupted before raw.json was written)",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "flat catalog price, equal to every recorded FLUX.3 call",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 2.18,
          "driftFromSeed": 26.39,
          "sharpness": 1.1553,
          "structureIoU": 0.2595,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            150.63,
            150.25,
            136.19
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            10.78,
            8.94,
            6.31
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            1.74,
            1.99,
            3.45
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 7,
          "slug": "glass",
          "frame": "flux3-07",
          "latencyMs": 37044,
          "latencySource": "file-mtime (run interrupted before raw.json was written)",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "flat catalog price, equal to every recorded FLUX.3 call",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 0.66,
          "driftFromSeed": 26.94,
          "sharpness": 1.1637,
          "structureIoU": 0.249,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            150.63,
            150.25,
            136.19
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            10.78,
            8.94,
            6.31
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            1.74,
            1.99,
            3.45
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 8,
          "slug": "second",
          "frame": "flux3-08",
          "latencyMs": 70356,
          "latencySource": "file-mtime (run interrupted before raw.json was written)",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "flat catalog price, equal to every recorded FLUX.3 call",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 3.11,
          "driftFromSeed": 26.83,
          "sharpness": 1.1537,
          "structureIoU": 0.2472,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            150.48,
            150.21,
            136.13
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            10.63,
            8.9,
            6.25
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            1.74,
            1.99,
            3.45
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 9,
          "slug": "mahkota",
          "frame": "flux3-09",
          "latencyMs": 33915,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 0.3,
          "driftFromSeed": 26.93,
          "sharpness": 1.1674,
          "structureIoU": 0.2456,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            150.48,
            150.21,
            136.13
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            10.63,
            8.9,
            6.25
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            1.74,
            1.99,
            3.45
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 10,
          "slug": "channel",
          "frame": "flux3-10",
          "latencyMs": 71388,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.024,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 1.3,
          "driftFromSeed": 27.28,
          "sharpness": 1.1771,
          "structureIoU": 0.2425,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            150.73,
            150.32,
            136.13
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            10.88,
            9.01,
            6.25
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            1.74,
            1.99,
            3.45
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "key": "seedream5flash",
      "label": "Seedream 5.0 Flash (1K)",
      "id": "bytedance-seed/seedream-5-0-flash",
      "vendor": "ByteDance",
      "request": {
        "resolution": "1K",
        "aspect_ratio": "16:9"
      },
      "stepsCompleted": 10,
      "seedSize": [
        1280,
        720
      ],
      "deliveredSizes": [
        [
          1280,
          720
        ]
      ],
      "analysisGrid": [
        768,
        432
      ],
      "seedCostUsd": 0.018,
      "seedLatencyMs": 18300,
      "costPerEditUsd": 0.018,
      "totalEditCostUsd": 0.18,
      "latencyMedianMs": 7766,
      "latencyTotalMs": 78789,
      "latencyFromFileTimestampsSteps": [],
      "costFlatCatalogSteps": [],
      "finalSharpness": 1.7973,
      "finalStructureIoU": 0.1006,
      "finalDriftFromSeed": 48.39,
      "medianStepDelta": 12.08,
      "minSharpness": 1.2885,
      "maxSharpness": 2.0112,
      "atmosphereShiftFinal": [
        -11.93,
        -19.33,
        -4.61
      ],
      "atmosphereShiftMagnitude": 23.18,
      "skyShiftFinal": [
        -44.87,
        -52.53,
        -42.37
      ],
      "skyShiftMagnitude": 81.04,
      "steps": [
        {
          "step": 0,
          "slug": "seed",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-00",
          "latencyMs": 18300,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 0.0,
          "driftFromSeed": 0.0,
          "sharpness": 1.0,
          "structureIoU": 1.0,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            128.77,
            133.45,
            127.74
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 1,
          "slug": "pool",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-01",
          "latencyMs": 8483,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 7.6,
          "driftFromSeed": 7.6,
          "sharpness": 1.2885,
          "structureIoU": 0.64,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            126.2,
            130.37,
            125.8
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -2.57,
            -3.08,
            -1.94
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -1.92,
            -2.66,
            -0.85
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 2,
          "slug": "tiles",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-02",
          "latencyMs": 8329,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 12.81,
          "driftFromSeed": 17.29,
          "sharpness": 1.7282,
          "structureIoU": 0.4352,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            121.98,
            126.56,
            124.63
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -6.79,
            -6.89,
            -3.11
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -5.25,
            -6.54,
            -3.4
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 3,
          "slug": "teak",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-03",
          "latencyMs": 7353,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 14.73,
          "driftFromSeed": 25.41,
          "sharpness": 2.0112,
          "structureIoU": 0.3203,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            127.07,
            127.98,
            124.42
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -1.7,
            -5.47,
            -3.32
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -5.3,
            -9.14,
            -6.0
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 4,
          "slug": "bale",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-04",
          "latencyMs": 7738,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 20.56,
          "driftFromSeed": 31.79,
          "sharpness": 2.0016,
          "structureIoU": 0.2398,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            126.06,
            126.01,
            124.76
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -2.71,
            -7.44,
            -2.98
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -8.11,
            -12.13,
            -7.14
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 5,
          "slug": "no-frangi",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-05",
          "latencyMs": 8361,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 11.35,
          "driftFromSeed": 34.68,
          "sharpness": 1.6725,
          "structureIoU": 0.1573,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            124.71,
            125.78,
            128.59
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -4.06,
            -7.67,
            0.85
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -13.2,
            -17.16,
            -10.61
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 6,
          "slug": "pebbles",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-06",
          "latencyMs": 7697,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 14.64,
          "driftFromSeed": 39.05,
          "sharpness": 1.7642,
          "structureIoU": 0.1355,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            125.85,
            126.41,
            133.7
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -2.92,
            -7.04,
            5.96
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -18.61,
            -22.85,
            -14.88
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 7,
          "slug": "glass",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-07",
          "latencyMs": 8048,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 7.13,
          "driftFromSeed": 40.5,
          "sharpness": 1.893,
          "structureIoU": 0.13,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            122.62,
            123.61,
            132.0
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -6.15,
            -9.84,
            4.26
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -24.2,
            -28.17,
            -18.32
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 8,
          "slug": "second",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-08",
          "latencyMs": 7552,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 18.38,
          "driftFromSeed": 44.08,
          "sharpness": 1.7051,
          "structureIoU": 0.1067,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            123.98,
            123.12,
            131.81
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -4.79,
            -10.33,
            4.07
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -28.28,
            -33.57,
            -23.72
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 9,
          "slug": "mahkota",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-09",
          "latencyMs": 7794,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 9.22,
          "driftFromSeed": 46.37,
          "sharpness": 1.7642,
          "structureIoU": 0.1036,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            119.89,
            117.82,
            127.21
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -8.88,
            -15.63,
            -0.53
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -37.35,
            -44.19,
            -33.28
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 10,
          "slug": "channel",
          "frame": "seedream5flash-10",
          "latencyMs": 7434,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.018,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1280,
          "height": 720,
          "stepDelta": 9.29,
          "driftFromSeed": 48.39,
          "sharpness": 1.7973,
          "structureIoU": 0.1006,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            116.84,
            114.12,
            123.13
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -11.93,
            -19.33,
            -4.61
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -44.87,
            -52.53,
            -42.37
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "key": "mai26flash",
      "label": "MAI-Image-2.6 Flash",
      "id": "microsoft/mai-image-2.6-flash",
      "vendor": "Microsoft",
      "request": {
        "aspect_ratio": "16:9"
      },
      "stepsCompleted": 10,
      "seedSize": [
        1360,
        768
      ],
      "deliveredSizes": [
        [
          1360,
          768
        ],
        [
          1365,
          768
        ]
      ],
      "analysisGrid": [
        768,
        434
      ],
      "seedCostUsd": 0.02006075,
      "seedLatencyMs": 13800,
      "costPerEditUsd": 0.02253,
      "totalEditCostUsd": 0.22532,
      "latencyMedianMs": 48316,
      "latencyTotalMs": 407876,
      "latencyFromFileTimestampsSteps": [],
      "costFlatCatalogSteps": [],
      "finalSharpness": 3.1006,
      "finalStructureIoU": 0.0554,
      "finalDriftFromSeed": 59.62,
      "medianStepDelta": 34.31,
      "minSharpness": 1.3822,
      "maxSharpness": 3.1006,
      "atmosphereShiftFinal": [
        -2.49,
        -13.94,
        -8.03
      ],
      "atmosphereShiftMagnitude": 16.28,
      "skyShiftFinal": [
        -21.0,
        -23.41,
        -25.65
      ],
      "skyShiftMagnitude": 40.58,
      "steps": [
        {
          "step": 0,
          "slug": "seed",
          "frame": "mai26flash-00",
          "latencyMs": 13800,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.02006075,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1360,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 0.0,
          "driftFromSeed": 0.0,
          "sharpness": 1.0,
          "structureIoU": 1.0,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            147.23,
            151.27,
            135.55
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            0.0,
            0.0,
            0.0
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 1,
          "slug": "pool",
          "frame": "mai26flash-01",
          "latencyMs": 52914,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.02252425,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 27.98,
          "driftFromSeed": 27.98,
          "sharpness": 1.3822,
          "structureIoU": 0.1423,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            149.59,
            152.84,
            134.94
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            2.36,
            1.57,
            -0.61
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            0.16,
            0.01,
            0.16
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 2,
          "slug": "tiles",
          "frame": "mai26flash-02",
          "latencyMs": 55723,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.02253525,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 31.32,
          "driftFromSeed": 35.45,
          "sharpness": 2.085,
          "structureIoU": 0.1087,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            146.03,
            149.51,
            131.3
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -1.2,
            -1.76,
            -4.25
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -4.27,
            -4.23,
            -3.62
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 3,
          "slug": "teak",
          "frame": "mai26flash-03",
          "latencyMs": 17975,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.0225335,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 36.9,
          "driftFromSeed": 41.52,
          "sharpness": 2.1343,
          "structureIoU": 0.0987,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            146.37,
            148.09,
            129.82
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -0.86,
            -3.18,
            -5.73
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -7.96,
            -8.2,
            -7.95
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 4,
          "slug": "bale",
          "frame": "mai26flash-04",
          "latencyMs": 18522,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.02253175,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 33.39,
          "driftFromSeed": 45.19,
          "sharpness": 1.9303,
          "structureIoU": 0.0875,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            145.32,
            144.64,
            128.11
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -1.91,
            -6.63,
            -7.44
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -12.35,
            -12.91,
            -12.98
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 5,
          "slug": "no-frangi",
          "frame": "mai26flash-05",
          "latencyMs": 49908,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.02252825,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 32.43,
          "driftFromSeed": 48.71,
          "sharpness": 1.8933,
          "structureIoU": 0.0616,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            140.89,
            139.42,
            125.17
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -6.34,
            -11.85,
            -10.38
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -18.21,
            -19.16,
            -19.09
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 6,
          "slug": "pebbles",
          "frame": "mai26flash-06",
          "latencyMs": 47414,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.02253,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 33.78,
          "driftFromSeed": 54.65,
          "sharpness": 2.1614,
          "structureIoU": 0.0541,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            144.84,
            139.88,
            134.77
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -2.39,
            -11.39,
            -0.78
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -24.81,
            -26.6,
            -26.69
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 7,
          "slug": "glass",
          "frame": "mai26flash-07",
          "latencyMs": 47334,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.0225265,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 35.85,
          "driftFromSeed": 57.83,
          "sharpness": 2.1969,
          "structureIoU": 0.0537,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            144.28,
            138.02,
            132.61
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -2.95,
            -13.25,
            -2.94
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -27.81,
            -29.78,
            -29.74
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 8,
          "slug": "second",
          "frame": "mai26flash-08",
          "latencyMs": 19525,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.022551,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 35.94,
          "driftFromSeed": 60.93,
          "sharpness": 2.3657,
          "structureIoU": 0.0542,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            142.59,
            134.02,
            127.97
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -4.64,
            -17.25,
            -7.58
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -33.9,
            -36.63,
            -37.04
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 9,
          "slug": "mahkota",
          "frame": "mai26flash-09",
          "latencyMs": 49218,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.02252475,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 34.85,
          "driftFromSeed": 61.4,
          "sharpness": 2.1419,
          "structureIoU": 0.0572,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            143.2,
            133.3,
            127.14
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -4.03,
            -17.97,
            -8.41
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -30.07,
            -31.85,
            -31.95
          ]
        },
        {
          "step": 10,
          "slug": "channel",
          "frame": "mai26flash-10",
          "latencyMs": 49343,
          "latencySource": "measured",
          "costUsd": 0.02253525,
          "costSource": "reported by the endpoint",
          "width": 1365,
          "height": 768,
          "stepDelta": 40.71,
          "driftFromSeed": 59.62,
          "sharpness": 3.1006,
          "structureIoU": 0.0554,
          "atmosphereTone": [
            144.74,
            137.33,
            127.52
          ],
          "atmosphereShift": [
            -2.49,
            -13.94,
            -8.03
          ],
          "skyShift": [
            -21.0,
            -23.41,
            -25.65
          ]
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "disclosures": [
    "Each model generated its own seed once, from the same prompt, in a separate step; the seeds were reused for the chains.",
    "One chain per model, no repeats. Differences between neighbouring figures can be run-to-run noise.",
    "Delivered resolution differs per model; every frame is resampled to its own seed's grid before measuring.",
    "FLUX.3 steps 1-8: the run was interrupted before the raw output was written, so latency for those steps comes from file modification times and cost is the flat per-image price that every other recorded FLUX.3 call carried.",
    "Sharpness, structure overlap and drift are measured against the seed, and the edits legitimately add and remove objects; they are comparable across models, not an absolute quality score."
  ],
  "notes": "FLUX.3 steps 1-8 ran in an interrupted run: cost is the flat per-image price (identical to all recorded FLUX.3 calls), latency is from file timestamps (latencySource). Seeds were generated once (seeds.json, object A) and reused for every chain."
}
